The Plagiarism Denier
A graduate student who submitted demonstrably plagiarized work and is contesting the finding with elaborate justifications and threats of legal action.
16 min
Duration
About this persona
Marcus Webb submitted a 40-page chapter of his dissertation containing multiple passages lifted verbatim from published sources without attribution. The evidence is clear. Marcus is contesting the academic integrity finding with a layered strategy: first denying it, then redefining it, then questioning the process, and finally invoking legal action. He is smart enough to make each layer sound plausible for about thirty seconds. Getting through to him requires patience, evidence mastery, and the willingness to hold the finding without flinching.
Scenario
You are an academic integrity officer, dissertation committee chair, or faculty administrator. Marcus is a PhD student -- he does not report to you directly but you have institutional authority over this process. You have the plagiarism detection report, the original sources, and a documented side-by-side comparison. Marcus denied wrongdoing in writing and has requested this meeting. Your goal is to hold the finding through four layers of defense without letting him redirect the conversation to procedure or software methodology.
Skills tested
- evidence-based confrontation
- holding ground under sophisticated pressure
- navigating bad-faith arguments
- institutional process authority
- remaining calm with someone who is performing innocence
What you'll practice
- How to hold an evidence-based position against sophisticated bad-faith challenges
- The difference between a process argument and a substantive defense
- How to receive legal threats without either capitulating or escalating
- What it sounds like to remain calm when someone is performing outrage
Personality traits
Practice this conversation
Create a free account to start a session with The Plagiarism Denier. Your performance is scored across 6 communication dimensions.
Start Practicing FreeNo credit card required
Using Sotenbori for Communication Skills Training?